Ruhr Economic Papers

Ruhr Economic Papers #897

Who will be the Mediator? Local Politics and Hospital Closures in Germany

by Ieva Sriubaite

RWI, 02/2021, 46 S./p., 10 Euro, ISBN 978-3-96973-037-9 DOI: 10.4419/96973037



This paper analyses the effects of hospital closures in Germany in the context of emergency medical care for patients with acute myocardial infarction or hemorrhagic stroke. Using a comprehensive inpatient care data, I evaluate the extent of the impact of hospital closures between 2006 and 2012 on geographical healthcare access and several patient clinical outcomes. To minimize bias from the potential endogeneity between the hospital quality and market structure, I employ an instrumental variable strategy and build a strong and highly relevant instrument in the context of municipal politics. Using collected data on the turnout of each local election in Germany, I compute a measure of concentration in political power that is estimated by the winning margin of the largest centre-right political party in Germany against the opposition. My findings suggest that: first, while patients living in closure-affected areas face worse healthcare access, this does not result in lower survival for acute medical cases; second, that a hospital closure mainly affects the access for rural residents and stimulates the efficiency of hospitals located in the more densely populated areas; and political power in the area plays an important role in shaping hospital’s future in the local market.

JEL-Classification: I11, I15, I18, I19

Keywords: Hospital closure; quality of care; municipality election; instrumental variable